Asset protection · International

Private foundation or trust: which suits a family with capital

Anna Kovalevskaya, Head of Legal, BRIDGESAnna KovalevskayaHead of Legal, BRIDGES

Updated: November 202612 min readExpert reviewed

Terms and costs verified: November 2026

A handshake over signed documents
Contents

A family that has decided to move capital out of personal ownership for succession and protection almost always chooses between two structures: a trust and a private foundation. Both separate property from the owner, set rules for distributions and survive the founder's death without breaking up the business. But they are built differently, and the difference determines how much control you keep and how banks and the tax authority will treat the structure. Here it is point by point.

TrustA relationship, trustee owns
FoundationLegal entity without members
More founder controlPrivate foundation
Russian CFC rulesApply to both

Key points

  • A trust is a relationship: the trustee owns the property for the beneficiaries. A private foundation is a legal entity without members that owns the property itself.
  • A foundation lets the founder lawfully keep more influence: in Liechtenstein, for example, the founder can reserve the right to amend the charter and revoke the foundation.
  • A trust is more flexible for succession over several generations and better known to English law and Asian banks.
  • For the Russian tax authority, both a trust and a foreign foundation fall under CFC rules if the founder keeps the right to receive income or property or to influence decisions.
  • The choice depends on where the capital is, which law is closer to the family, how much control is needed and which banks will serve the structure.

The key difference: a relationship or an organisation

The trust comes from English law, where ownership can be split: legally the property belongs to the trustee, and the beneficiaries enjoy the benefit. It is not an organisation or a legal entity. A trust has no charter, no bodies and no entry in a commercial register. There is a trust deed, a trustee and rules the trustee must follow.

A private foundation is a civil law invention, the answer of countries such as Liechtenstein and Austria to the English trust. It is a legal entity with a charter and governing bodies, but without members or shareholders. The property belongs to the foundation itself, and neither the founder nor the beneficiaries can treat it as theirs. A council manages the foundation, often overseen by a protector or supervisory body. In essence, a foundation is a trust in the form of an organisation.

CriterionTrustPrivate foundation
Legal natureA relationship, not a legal entityA legal entity with no members or shareholders
Who owns the propertyThe trusteeThe foundation itself
Who managesThe trustee, overseen by a protectorThe foundation council, often with a protector or supervisory body
Founder's rightsMinimal after transfer, otherwise risk of being treated as a shamMany laws allow the founder to keep rights to amend the charter and revoke the foundation
RegistrationUsually not publicly registered but entered in beneficial ownership registersRegistered or deposited with a state authority
Home lawEngland and common law countriesLiechtenstein, Austria, Panama, Malta, the UAE
Familiarity for a client from RussiaNeeds explanation: alien to Russian lawCloser to familiar logic: an organisation with a charter
Commercial activityThe trustee can own companiesUsually prohibited directly, conducted through subsidiaries

This difference has practical consequences. A foundation is easier to explain to a notary, a bank or a court in a civil law country: it has a charter, a register extract, bodies and a seal. A trust works better where it is known: the United Kingdom, English law islands, Singapore and Hong Kong. For a client from Russia a foundation is usually more intuitive, while a trust needs more explanation, and that is no small matter when a structure must work for decades.

How much control the founder keeps

This is the main question for an entrepreneur. In a trust, the settlor must let go of the property: if he continues to dispose of it in practice, a court may find the trust a sham. There are reserved powers trusts in which the settlor keeps investment decisions, but each such reservation weakens protection. These risks are covered in our article on how a trust works.

A foundation gives more lawful room. Liechtenstein's Persons and Companies Act, as reformed in 2009, expressly allows the founder to reserve the right to revoke the foundation and amend its charter. The founder can sit on the foundation council or appoint its members. This is convenient but cuts both ways: the more rights the founder has, the easier it is for creditors and the tax authority to argue the property is in fact his. For creditor protection the founder's rights have to be limited; for running the business they can be kept.

Hence a rule: first decide what matters more, protection or management. If the goal is to pass the business to the children while keeping the final say during your lifetime, a foundation with limited founder rights that pass to the council on death usually suits. If the goal is to protect capital from future business risks, an irrevocable trust or a foundation in which the founder has waived the right of revocation is a better fit.

Succession: what happens after the founder's death

Both a trust and a foundation solve the main succession problem: the property is not part of the estate, so there is no wait for probate in several countries. After the founder's death management continues under pre-agreed rules, and distributions go to those he named. The business is not split among heirs, and none of them can demand that a share be carved out.

But forced heirship does not disappear. In Russia, Article 1149 of the Civil Code guarantees minor and disabled children, a disabled spouse and parents at least half of the share they would have received by law, an inheritance rule that applies regardless of the will. Heirs may challenge a transfer of property into a foundation or trust if it violated their rights. Many foundation and trust countries shield their structures from foreign forced heirship law, but a dispute is still possible. Planning across several countries is covered in our article on succession with property abroad.

For those who want to solve the question in Russia there is a domestic instrument, the personal fund. It is created under the Civil Code, requires at least RUB 100 million in the founder's lifetime and is liable for the founder's debts for three years. For Russian assets it is often a sensible alternative to a foreign foundation.

Anna Kovalevskaya

Anna KovalevskayaHead of Legal, BRIDGES

Foundation or trust

Not sure whether to choose a foundation or a trust? We will compare them for your family

We will look at your assets, countries and tax residence and propose a structure banks will accept.

Signing documents in a meeting room

Taxes: the structure's country and the family's country

Taxes are calculated at two levels. The first is the structure's own country. Many foundation and trust countries tax them minimally or exempt them provided the foundation does not carry on commercial activity locally, but conditions differ and are checked before setup. The second level is the country of residence of the founder and beneficiaries. That is where the main tax burden arises.

For a Russian tax resident, both a trust and a foreign foundation fall under the rules on controlled foreign companies. The Tax Code expressly names foundations and trusts among foreign structures without legal personality. According to the Federal Tax Service, a founder is a controlling person if he has or retains the right to receive the structure's income or property, to dispose of it or otherwise influence decisions. He then notifies the tax authority, and the structure's profit above RUB 10 million a year may be taxed in Russia. Details are in our article on CFCs, trusts and foundations.

This is where the paradox of choice shows. The more rights the founder keeps in a foundation, the more likely he is a controlling person with tax consequences. The fewer rights, the more likely a beneficiary becomes the controlling person. So the tax model is built in advance with tax coordination, not after registration.

How banks treat foundations and trusts

The bank is the main filter. It needs to understand who the ultimate beneficial owner is, where the property came from and why this particular structure was chosen. Continental European banks usually accept Liechtenstein and Austrian foundations more readily, while Singapore and London banks prefer trusts. A structure from a country the bank considers risky may wait months for an account or never get one.

For clients with a Russian passport or residence, banks add their own requirements. A clear source of wealth, sanctions screening and an understandable purpose are needed. That is why we start the choice between a foundation and a trust with the question of which bank will hold the account, not with which structure is fashionable. On banks and second passports, see second passport and banks.

Confidentiality and registers

Neither a foundation nor a trust offers anonymity today. A foundation is registered or deposited with a state authority: in Liechtenstein, a private foundation that does not carry on commercial activity is usually not entered in the commercial register but deposits its documents with the Office of Justice. A trust is not registered as an organisation, but the United Kingdom has run a trust register since 2017, and in EU countries information on the beneficial owners of trusts and foundations goes into national beneficial ownership registers.

Public access to these registers has narrowed: in November 2022 the EU Court of Justice held that unrestricted access by the general public to beneficial ownership information is incompatible with the right to privacy. But banks, tax authorities and persons with a legitimate interest keep access. So the confidentiality of a foundation or trust means protection from the curious, not from the state or the bank.

Administration and ongoing obligations

Both structures require ongoing support. A trust needs a licensed trustee to keep records, decide on distributions and answer banks' questions. A foundation needs a council. In Liechtenstein the law requires the governing body of a legal entity that does not carry on commercial activity to include at least one member authorised under the local professional trustees act. In Austria the board of a private foundation has at least three members, two of whom must live in EU or EEA countries.

On top of this come bookkeeping, sometimes an audit, annual fees, registered agent services and preparing reports for the family's tax authorities. These costs are worth calculating in advance: a structure that costs more to maintain than it saves or protects loses its point. For modest capital it is more sensible to start with a marital agreement, a will and accounts in two countries.

What to choose: six typical situations

Your situationWhat usually suitsWhy
You want to keep influence over decisions during your lifetimePrivate foundationThe right to amend the charter and revoke the foundation can be built in under the foundation's law
Succession over generations is the priority, and you are ready to hand over managementTrustFlexibility of a discretionary trust and well-developed case law
Capital in Europe, civil law clients and banksPrivate foundationThe structure is familiar to notaries, courts and banks of continental Europe
Capital in Asia or in English law instrumentsTrustSingapore, Hong Kong and English law banks are used to trusts
A structure is needed to hold a family businessFoundation or purpose trustBoth allow shares to be held without human members
Maximum creditor protection mattersTrust in a specialised jurisdictionShort limitation periods and strict standards of proof

Both instruments are often used together. For example, a private foundation owns the holding company of the family business, while a separate trust holds an investment portfolio for the children. Or a purpose trust owns the shares of a company that manages the foundation. Such combinations make sense for large capital and assets in several countries. For a modest fortune, simpler is better: one structure, one bank, clear documents.

Can the decision be changed later

The choice is not necessarily final, but restructuring costs more than choosing correctly at the outset. A trust can be changed if the trust deed gives the trustee or protector power to amend it, change the governing law or move the trust to another country. In some countries a foundation can be moved to another jurisdiction while keeping its legal personality, if the laws of both countries allow it. Sometimes the property is simply transferred from one structure to another, for example from a trust to a foundation.

Each such change is checked from three angles. Does it trigger tax in the structure's country or the family's country? How will the bank react, since it will re-examine the beneficial owners and the source of funds? And does it give creditors or heirs grounds to challenge the transfer? That is why flexibility should be built into the documents from the start: how to replace the trustee and council members, move to another country and add new beneficiaries.

Where foundations and trusts are set up

For foundations, the usual choices are Liechtenstein, Austria, Panama, Malta and the UAE. For trusts, Singapore, Cyprus, the British Virgin Islands, Jersey and the Cayman Islands. Differences in minimum capital, council requirements, taxes and confidentiality are collected in our review of jurisdictions for a private foundation.

The order of work

Step 1

Goal

Decide what matters more: running the business, succession, protection from risks.

Step 2

Asset map

Establish where the assets are and which banks will hold the accounts.

Step 3

Tax model

Check the consequences for the founder and beneficiaries in their countries.

Step 4

Structure and country

Choose a foundation or trust and the jurisdiction, allocate the founder's rights.

Step 5

Documents

Prepare the charter or trust deed, distribution rules and a letter of wishes.

Step 6

Bank and reporting

Open accounts, file notifications and update documents when the family changes.

Common mistakes

  • Choosing by fashion. "Our friends have a trust" is not an argument; goals and banks decide.
  • Keeping all the rights. Convenient, but it removes protection and creates tax consequences.
  • Forgetting forced heirship. Heirs can challenge the transfer of property.
  • Not checking the bank in advance. A structure without an account does not work.
  • Setting it up and forgetting it. Marriage, divorce and relocation require a review of documents.

What this means for you. If keeping influence over decisions matters to you and your capital is in Europe, start with a private foundation. If the goal is succession over generations and you are ready to hand management to a professional, consider a trust. In both cases the family's tax residence and the bank are decisive. We will compare the options for your situation and prepare the documents.

You can start with an online consultation or our page on legal structures. The general approach is in our article on asset protection, and terms are in the glossary: private interest foundation, parties to a trust.

Share this article

Still have questions? We'll answer for your case

Tell us what you want to solve, and an expert on the topic will contact you.

Sofia Mendes, BRIDGES
Citizenship
Dmitry Nagy, BRIDGES
Taxes
Hanna Berger, BRIDGES
Inheritance

Frequently asked

Questions people ask before deciding

01How does a private foundation differ from a trust?

A trust is a relationship in which the trustee owns the property. A private foundation is a legal entity without members that owns the property itself.

02Where does the founder keep more control?

In a private foundation. The law of some countries, such as Liechtenstein, lets the founder keep the right to amend the charter and revoke the foundation. But this weakens creditor protection.

03Which is better for succession?

Both take property out of the estate. A trust is more flexible over several generations; a foundation is more familiar to continental European banks and courts.

04How are foundations and trusts taxed in Russia?

For a Russian tax resident, both fall under CFC rules if the founder keeps the right to receive income or property or to influence decisions.

05Can forced heirship be avoided?

There is no guarantee. Heirs entitled to a forced share may challenge the transfer of property if it violated their rights.

06Can a foundation and a trust be used together?

Yes, for large capital: for example, a foundation owns the family business and a trust holds the investment portfolio.

About the author

Anna Kovalevskaya, Head of Legal, BRIDGES

Author: Anna Kovalevskaya

Head of Legal, BRIDGES

I have worked with citizenship and residency matters in European countries for 12 years. Programme requirements and application practices change, so I assess each matter against the current rules, the applicant's immigration history, family composition and the documents supporting the legal basis for the application.

News+3 stories on 11 November

Related news

All news
Foundation or trust

Choosing between a foundation and a trust? Write to us and we will compare and set it up

We will compare the structures against your assets, taxes and banks, choose the country and prepare documents.

BRIDGES · since 2004

Have a question? Ask our lawyer

Our lawyer will answer your questions and tell you where to start.

Confidential · no obligations · answered by the relevant specialist

Or message us on WhatsApp or Telegram

Anna KovalevskayaHead of Legal, BRIDGES
Anna Kovalevskaya, Head of Legal, BRIDGES